Clean Curious

Clean Today for a Better Tomorrow

Kirkland Toilet Paper vs Charmin: The 7 Most Important Differences

kirkland toilet paper vs charmin

Last Updated on October 18, 2023

Toilet paper is an essential commodity that every toilet needs to maintain hygienic standards. Two popular brands often come to mind when choosing the right toilet paper for your home: Charmin and Kirkland. While both offer a range of options to cater to various preferences, they differ in several key aspects.

Charmin is renowned for its soft and plush texture, while Kirkland toilet paper may feel rougher due to its sturdier texture. Also, Charmin is known for its strength and durability, even when wet, but Kirkland toilet paper is generally less durable, which could lead to using more sheets.

With this article, we’ll explore the key differences between Kirkland and Charmin so that you can make an informed decision. We’ll also explore what plumbers recommend and why Charmin might have the edge. So let’s find out.

Kirkland Toilet Paper vs Charmin: Key Differences to Consider

Kirkland Toilet Paper vs Charmin- Key Differences to Consider

When choosing between Kirkland toilet paper and Charmin, several key differences exist, such as:

  • Texture and comfort
  • Sheet count and cost
  • Absorbency
  • Strength and pipe clogging
  • Environmental considerations
  • Affordability

Texture and Comfort

To feel the difference in texture and comfort between Kirkland and Charmin, you’ll notice that Charmin toilet paper is softer and more gentle on your skin.

With its renowned plushness, Charmin provides a luxurious experience that many users appreciate. The toilet paper feels velvety smooth to the touch, offering comfort that can make your bathroom routine more enjoyable.

On the other hand, Kirkland paper has a sturdier texture, which may feel rougher compared to Charmin. While some people prefer this sturdiness, others might find it less comfortable on their skin.

Sheet Count and Cost

Charmin toilet paper typically provides more sheets per roll than Kirkland, making it a cost-effective option for those seeking quantity. With 214 2-ply sheets per roll, it offers a generous supply of toilet paper. The average cost per sheet is approximately 0.35 cents, allowing you to balance quantity and affordability.

However, Kirkland surpasses Charmin regarding sheet count with 425 2-ply sheets per roll. This higher sheet count makes Kirkland an appealing choice for those prioritizing having a larger supply. Also, the lower cost per sheet at approximately 0.13 cents further enhances the value proposition of Kirkland toilet paper.


For a more effective cleaning experience, consider the absorbency rate of the two options. Charmin toilet paper is known for its superior liquid-absorbing power, so you may need to use less to achieve the desired cleanliness.

In contrast, Kirkland toilet paper may have a lower absorbency rate than Charmin. This could potentially result in needing to use more units of Kirkland toilet paper for effective cleaning.

Strength and Pipe Clogging

When comparing Kirkland and Charmin, Charmin is known for its superior strength and ability to withstand more force before tearing. However, this strength has a potential downside: its thicker materials may occasionally lead to clogging in narrow pipes.

Meanwhile, Kirkland toilet paper is designed to dissolve quickly in the toilet due to its thinner materials. Its thinner ply could result in quicker tearing and disintegration, so you might use more sheets to complete the job. However, Kirkland may be slightly weaker in terms of overall strength when compared to Charmin.

Environmental Considerations

Regarding Charmin, some variations are FSC-certified, which means they source their materials responsibly. However, there needs to be more information available regarding its overall environmental practices and ingredients.

Meanwhile, the article must detail Kirkland’s environmental certifications or practices. If eco-friendliness is a priority for you, further research may be necessary to determine if Kirkland toilet paper meets your sustainability standards.


Kirkland toilet paper is known for being more budget-friendly compared to Charmin. While Charmin is a premium brand that typically comes at a higher price point, Kirkland offers a cheaper option for those looking to save money.

One of the reasons for this is that Kirkland toilet paper is often available in bulk quantities, allowing you to purchase more rolls at a lower unit price. This can particularly benefit households or businesses that go through toilet paper quickly.

Alternatively, if you prioritize premium quality over cost savings, Charmin might be the better choice despite its higher price tag.

What toilet paper do plumbers recommend?

Plumbers recommend using single-ply toilet paper (regardless of toilet paper brands like Kirkland or Charmin) because it breaks down faster and helps prevent clogs in your pipes.

The thinner composition of 1-ply toilet paper dissolves faster when flushed, reducing the risk of clogs forming in your pipes.

Which Charmin is better: red or blue?

If you’re wondering which Charmin is better, the red bears indicate strong Charmin while the blue bears represent softness. The choice between strength and softness ultimately depends on your preferences and needs.

Red Charmin is designed to provide stronger toilet paper to hold well during use. It is durable and less likely to leave any residue behind. Conversely, Blue Charmin focuses more on delivering a gentle and luxurious feel.

Is Kirkland toilet paper a good brand?

Is Kirkland toilet paper a good brand

Although Kirkland toilet paper has softness, its strength is only so-so, according to Consumer Reports. This means it may feel nice against your skin but not hold up well during use.

Consumer ratings on the same report also reflect this sentiment, with a majority of one-star reviews. However, keep in mind that individual experiences differ, and what works for one person may not work for someone else. Some customers may find Kirkland toilet paper perfectly adequate for their needs.

Kirkland or Charmin Toilet Paper: Make the Right Choice to Enjoy an Exceptional Bathroom Experience

After comparing Kirkland Toilet Paper and Charmin, it is clear that there are some key differences to consider. While both brands have their strengths, plumbers often recommend Charmin for its durability and clog-free performance.

Also, Charmin offers two options: red or blue, with the red version softer and more luxurious. With its strong reputation in the market, Charmin is the better choice overall.

However, note that Kirkland toilet paper is still a good brand that provides decent quality at a more affordable price point. Ultimately, the decision between these two brands for toilet paper will depend on your preferences and budget.

Kirkland Toilet Paper vs Charmin: The 7 Most Important Differences

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top